Hours after the BJP claimed that the ruling party has lost majority in Himachal Pradesh, Chief Minister Sukhvinder Singh Sukhu has alleged that five or six Congress MLAs were taken to Haryana accompanied by a convoy of the state’s police and the Central Reserve Police Force. Mr Sukhu’s claim comes amid reports of six Congress MLAs cross-voting for the BJP in the Rajya Sabha polls on Tuesday.
BJP sources have hinted that the party will move a no-confidence motion against the Sukhu government on Thursday after there were indications that six Congress MLAs and three independents backing the party had voted for the BJP candidate in the Rajya Sabha election. The Congress, which has 40 MLAs in the 68-member Himachal Assembly, was expected to secure a comfortable win for its candidate, Abhishek Manu Singhvi.
Moving the Congress MLAs to Haryana, a BJP-ruled state, is believed to be part of the party’s preparation for the no-confidence vote. The BJP has 25 MLAs.
“Counting for the Rajya Sabha polls is taking place and the way the BJP leaders are threatening the counting officers is not good for democracy. They have stopped counting for a long time. I will request BJP leaders to remain patient and not put pressure on people,” Mr Sukhu said in Hindi.
“The way 5-6 MLAs have been taken by a convoy of the Haryana Police and the CRPF… The MLAs’ families are trying to get in touch with them and the legislators should contact them. There is no need to worry. There is a government and an opposition in a democracy but the kind of hooliganism (gundagardi) being done by the opposition will never be accepted by the people of Himachal,” he asserted.
The INDIA bloc finished last week on a high after the Congress sealed a pan-India seat-share deal with the Aam Aadmi Party, and another with the Samajwadi Party for Uttar Pradesh, ahead of the 2024 Lok Sabha election. The Congress-led bloc was also close to an accord with the Shiv Sena (UBT) and Nationalist Congress Party (SCP) in Maharashtra and reached out to Bengal’s Trinamool.
Confidence in the opposition ranks, therefore, was high going into Tuesday’s Rajya Sabha poll.
That confidence took a hit by close of voting after six Congress MLAs in Himachal Pradesh, as well as three independent MLAs, and seven Samajwadi Party lawmakers in Uttar Pradesh cross-voted.
READ | Cross-Voting In Himachal, Tight Race In UP In Rajya Sabha Polls
Unsurprisingly, the 16 votes went to Bharatiya Janata Party candidates, with the party now set to claim one additional seat in each state and receive a prestige boost ahead of the Lok Sabha election.
There was some encouragement from Karnataka, where the Congress held on to three seats – thanks to the support of two independent MLAs, two from local parties, and one BJP cross-voting lawmaker.
The defeats – discounting the fact it strengthens the BJP’s hand – underlines the extent of the challenge facing INDIA in the general election, in which the BJP plans to win 370 seats on its own.
They will also make the Congress’ task of negotiating seat-share deals in other states even harder.
The party is already under pressure – the stand-off with Mamata Banerjee in Bengal is a good example – to scale down its demands with allies pointing to its recent dismal electoral track record.
A significant point in all of this is two of the three states in which the BJP forced an election – and has now won two additional Rajya Sabha seats – are ruled by eternal rivals, the Congress.
The Congress swept to power in the hill state just under two years ago; the party won 40 of 68 Assembly seats in a rare big (and solo) win for the party. The BJP won just 25 seats.
There was only one vacant seat, and the Congress nominated Abhishek Singhvi, expecting a comfortable win for the senior leader. Mr Singhvi needed only 35 votes to be confirmed.
The Congress should have closed this poll in double-quick time. However, the two sides are now at 34 votes each after six Congress MLAs (and three independents) voted for the BJP candidate instead.
Sources told NDTV the cross-voting MLAs were Sudhir Sharma, Rajendra Rana, Ravi Thakur, Indradutt Lakhanpal, Chaitanya Sharma, and Devendra Bhutto.
READ | 6 Himachal Congress MLAs Taken to BJP-ruled Haryana: Chief Minister Sukhu
Hours after polling closed, there was more drama; the six, and the three independents, were reportedly taken to Panchkula in BJP-ruled Haryana, according to Chief Minister Sukhvinder Sukhu.
READ | Congress Has “Lost Majority” In Himachal: BJP’s Jairam Thakur
A further fallout sees the BJP now claiming the Congress government is in the minority, and talk of a floor test less than halfway through a five-year term, is now being discussed.
There are 10 Rajya Sabha seats available in the state this year.
Of these, the BJP, with 252 MLAs on its books (plus 18 allied votes), has seven seats locked, while the SP, with 108 lawmakers and a handful from its allies, was looking at a three-seat return.
Now it appears the BJP will claim an eighth seat, thanks to seven cross-voting Samajwadi Party MLAs and support from Jayant Chaudhary’s Rashtriya Lok Dal.
The RLD is an INDIA member for now, but is expected to switch to the BJP-led alliance shortly.
READ | In Rajya Sabha Poll, Akhilesh Yadav Says 3rd Seat Bid Was “Test”
Mr Yadav – who was dealt a shock early this morning (and a clear sign of what was to come) after his Chief Whip and three MLAs were spotted with the BJP – has now claimed the third seat was a “test”.
The southern state – also Congress-ruled – had four seats falling vacant.
The ruling party was expected to claim the three it held without fuss, since it has 134 MLAs to the 85 between the BJP and its ally, the Janata Dal (Secular), and needed only one more to do just that.
As it transpired, the Congress polled 139 overall – including ST Somashekar, the BJP MLA who cross-voted – allowing Ajay Maken, Dr Syed Naseer Hussain, and GC Chandrashekhar victories.
The BJP had enough – 45 votes are needed – to retain its one seat, won by Narayana Bandage.
Apart from these, 41 seats have been filled unopposed.
The list includes former Congress boss Sonia Gandhi, who leaves her seat in the party stronghold of Raebareli in UP – maybe to Priyanaka Gandhi Vadra – after holding it since she won it in 2004.
READ | Sonia Gandhi Shifts To Rajya Sabha. End Of Era, Big Change For Congress
BJP boss JP Nadda has been moved from Himachal Pradesh – after the party lost the state – to Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s home state of Gujarat. Union ministers Ashwini Vaishnaw (Odisha) and L Murugan (Madhya Pradesh) were also elected without fuss, as was ex-Congressman Ashok Chavan.
Mr Chavan, with the Congress for decades, quit two weeks ago and joined the BJP hours later.
NDTV is now available on WhatsApp channels. Click on the link to get all the latest updates from NDTV on your chat.